Farmers, advisors and researchers should know which herbicides are best suited to combat specific resistant weeds. To support the use of herbicides suitable for resistance management the enclosed classification of herbicides is proposed.
The herbicides are classified alphabetically according to their target sites, modes of action, similarity of induced symptoms or chemical classes.
If different herbicide groups share the same mode or site of action only one letter is used. In the case of photosynthesis inhibitors subclasses C1, C2 and C3 indicate different binding behaviour at the binding protein D1 or different classes. Bleaching can be caused by different ways. Accordingly subgroups F1, F2 and F3 are introduced. Growth inhibition can be induced by herbicides from subgroups K1, K2 and K3. Herbicides with unknown modes or sites of action are classified in group Z as "unknown" until they can be grouped exactly.
Classification of Herbicides
In order to avoid confusion with I and O categories J and Q are omitted. New herbicides will be classified in the respective groups or in new groups (R, S, T...).
Since the system was in part developed in co-operation with the "Weed Science Society of America (WSSA)" new herbicides should be categorised jointly by HRAC and WSSA.
For reference the numerical system of the WSSA is listed, too.
The aim of HRAC is to create a uniform classification of herbicide modes of action in as many countries as possible.
Such a classification system can be useful for many instances but there are cases where weeds exhibit multiple resistance across many of the groups listed and in these cases the key may be of limited value.
The system itself is not based on resistance risk assessment but can be used by the farmer or advisor as a tool to choose herbicides in different mode of action groups, so that mixtures or rotations of active ingredients can be planned.
February 2000
HRAC: Herbicide classification
| HRAC Group | Mode of Action | Chemical Family | Active Ingredient | WSSA Group |
|
A |
Inhibition of acetyl CoA carboxylase (ACCase) |
Aryloxyphenoxy- propionates ‘FOPs’ |
clodinafop-propargyl cyhalofop-butyl diclofop-methyl fenoxaprop-P-ethyl fluazifop-P-butyl haloxyfop-R-methyl propaquizafop quizalofop-P-ethyl |
1 |
|
Cyclohexanediones ‘DIMs’ |
alloxydim butroxydim (clefoxydim proposed) clethodim cycloxydim sethoxydim tepraloxydin tralkoxydim |
|||
|
B |
Inhibition of acetolactate synthase ALS (acetohydroxyacid synthase AHAS) |
Sulfonylureas |
amidosulfuron azimsulfuron bensulfuron-methyl chlorimuron-ethyl chlorsulfuron cinosulfuron cyclosulfamuron ethametsulfuron-methyl ethoxysulfuron flazasulfuron flupyrsulfuron-methyl-Na foramsulfuron halosulfuron-methyl imazosulfuron iodosulfuron metsulfuron-methyl nicosulfuron oxasulfuron primisulfuron-methyl prosulfuron pyrazosulfuron-ethyl rimsulfuron sulfometuron-methyl sulfosulfuron thifensulfuron-methyl triasulfuron tribenuron-methyl trifloxysulfuron triflusulfuron-methyl tritosulfuron |
2 |
| Imidazolinones |
imazapic imazamethabenz-methyl imazamox imazapyr imazaquin imazethapyr |
|||
| Triazolopyrimidines |
cloransulam-methyl diclosulam florasulam flumetsulam metosulam |
|||
| Pyrimidinyl(thio)benzoates |
bispyribac-Na pyribenzoxim pyriftalid pyrithiobac-Na pyriminobac-methyl |
|||
|
Sulfonylaminocarbonyl- triazolinones |
flucarbazone-Na procarbazone-Na |
February 2000
HRAC: Herbicide classification
| HRAC Group | Mode of Action | Chemical Family | Active Ingredient | WSSA Group |
|
C1 |
Inhibition of photosynthesis at photosystem II |
Triazines |
ametryne atrazine cyanazine desmetryne dimethametryne prometon prometryne propazine simazine simetryne terbumeton terbuthylazine terbutryne trietazine |
5 |
| Triazinones |
hexazinone metamitron metribuzin |
|||
| Triazolinone | amicarbazone | |||
| Uracils |
bromacil lenacil terbacil |
|||
| Pyridazinones | pyrazon = chloridazon | |||
| Phenyl-carbamates |
desmedipham phenmedipham |
|||
|
C2 |
Inhibition of photosynthesis at photosystem II |
Ureas |
chlorobromuron chlorotoluron chloroxuron dimefuron diuron ethidimuron fenuron fluometuron (see F3) isoproturon isouron linuron methabenzthiazuron metobromuron metoxuron monolinuron neburon siduron tebuthiuron |
7 |
| Amides |
propanil pentanochlor |
|||
|
C3 |
Inhibition of photosynthesis at photosystem II |
Nitriles |
bromofenoxim (also M) bromoxynil (also group M) ioxynil (also group M) |
6 |
| Benzothiadiazinone | bentazon | |||
| Phenyl-pyridazines |
pyridate pyridafol |
|||
|
D |
Photosystem-I-electron diversion | Bipyridyliums |
diquat paraquat |
22 |
February 2000
HRAC: Herbicide classification
| HRAC Group | Mode of Action | Chemical Family | Active Ingredient | WSSA Group |
|
E |
Inhibition of protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPO) |
Diphenylethers |
acifluorfen-Na bifenox chlomethoxyfen fluoroglycofen-ethyl fomesafen halosafen lactofen oxyfluorfen |
14 |
| Phenylpyrazoles |
fluazolate pyraflufen-ethyl |
|||
| N-phenylphthalimides |
cinidon-ethyl flumioxazin flumiclorac-pentyl |
|||
| Thiadiazoles |
fluthiacet-methyl thidiazimin |
|||
| Oxadiazoles |
oxadiazon oxadiargyl |
|||
| Triazolinones |
azafenidin carfentrazone-ethyl sulfentrazone |
|||
| Oxazolidinediones | pentoxazone | |||
| Pyrimidindiones |
benzfendizone butafenacil |
|||
| Others |
pyrazogyl profluazol |
|||
|
F1 |
Bleaching: Inhibition of carotenoid biosynthesis at the phytoene desaturase step (PDS) |
Pyridazinones | norflurazon |
12 |
| Pyridinecarboxamides |
diflufenican picolinafen |
|||
| Others |
beflubutamid fluridone flurochloridone flurtamone |
|||
|
F2 |
Bleaching: Inhibition of 4-hydroxyphenyl-pyruvate-dioxygenase (4-HPPD) |
Triketones |
mesotrione sulcotrione |
28 |
| Isoxazoles |
isoxachlortole isoxaflutole |
|||
| Pyrazoles |
benzofenap pyrazolynate pyrazoxyfen |
|||
| Others | benzobicyclon | |||
|
F3 |
Bleaching: Inhibition of carotenoid biosynthesis (unknown target) |
Triazoles |
amitrole (in vivo inhibition of lycopene cyclase) |
11 |
| Isoxazolidinones | clomazone |
13 |
||
| Ureas | fluometuron (see C2) | |||
| Diphenylether | aclonifen | |||
|
G |
Inhibition of EPSP synthase | Glycines |
glyphosate sulfosate |
9 |
|
H |
Inhibition of glutamine synthetase | Phosphinic acids |
glufosinate-ammonium bialaphos = bilanaphos |
10 |
February 2000
HRAC: Herbicide classification
| HRAC Group | Mode of Action | Chemical Family | Active Ingredient | WSSA Group |
|
I |
Inhibition of DHP (dihydropteroate) synthase | Carbamates | asulam |
18 |
|
K1 |
Microtubule assembly inhibition | Dinitroanilines |
benefin = benfluralin butralin dinitramine ethalfluralin oryzalin pendimethalin trifluralin |
3 |
| Phosphoroamidates |
amiprophos-methyl butamiphos |
|||
| Pyridines |
dithiopyr thiazopyr |
|||
| Benzamides |
propyzamide = pronamide tebutam |
|||
| Benzenedicarboxylic acids | DCPA = chlorthal-dimethyl |
3 |
||
|
K2 |
Inhibition of mitosis / microtubule organisation | Carbamates |
chlorpropham propham carbetamide |
23 |
|
K3 |
Inhibition of cell division (Inhibition of VLCFAs; see Remarks) |
Chloroacetamides |
acetochlor alachlor butachlor |
15 |
|
dimethachlor dimethanamid metazachlor metolachlor pethoxamid |
||||
|
pretilachlor propachlor propisochlor thenylchlor |
||||
| Acetamides |
diphenamid napropamide naproanilide |
|||
| Oxyacetamides |
flufenacet mefenacet |
|||
| Tetrazolinones | fentrazamide | |||
| Others |
anilofos cafenstrole indanofan piperophos |
|||
|
L |
Inhibition of cell wall (cellulose) synthesis | Nitriles |
dichlobenil chlorthiamid |
20 |
| Benzamides | isoxaben |
21 |
||
| Triazolocarboxamides | flupoxam |
February 2000
HRAC: Herbicide classification
| HRAC Group | Mode of Action | Chemical Family | Active Ingredient | WSSA Group |
|
M |
Uncoupling (Membrane disruption) | Dinitrophenols |
DNOC dinoseb dinoterb |
24 |
|
N |
Inhibition of lipid synthesis - not ACCase inhibition | Thiocarbamates |
butylate cycloate dimepiperate EPTC esprocarb molinate orbencarb pebulate prosulfocarb thiobencarb = benthiocarb tiocarbazil triallate vernolate |
8 |
| Phosphorodithioates | bensulide | |||
| Benzofuranes |
benfuresate ethofumesate |
|||
| Chloro-Carbonic-acids |
TCA dalapon flupropanate |
26 |
||
|
O |
Action like indole acetic acid (synthetic auxins) |
Phenoxy-carboxylic-acids |
clomeprop 2,4-D 2,4-DB dichlorprop = 2,4-DP MCPA MCPB mecoprop = MCPP = CMPP |
4 |
| Benzoic acids |
chloramben dicamba TBA |
|||
|
Pyridine carboxylic acids |
clopyralid fluroxypyr picloram triclopyr |
|||
| Quinoline carboxylic acids |
quinclorac (also group L) quinmerac |
|||
| Others | benazolin-ethyl | |||
|
P |
Inhibition of auxin transport |
Phthalamates Semicarbazones |
naptalam diflufenzopyr-Na |
19 |
February 2000
HRAC: Herbicide classification
| HRAC Group | Mode of Action | Chemical Family | Active Ingredient | WSSA Group |
|
R |
... | ... | ... | |
|
S |
... | ... | ... | |
|
. |
... | ... | ... | |
|
Z |
Unknown | Arylaminopropionic acids | Flamprop-M-methyl /-isopropyl |
25 |
| Pyrazolium | difenzoquat |
8 |
||
| Organoarsenicals |
DSMA MSMA |
17 |
||
| Others |
bromobutide (chloro)-flurenol |
27 |
||
| cinmethylin | ||||
| cumyluron | ||||
| dazomet | ||||
|
dymron = daimuron methyl-dimuron= methyl-dymron etobenzanid fosamine metam oxaziclomefone oleic acid |
||||
|
pelargonic acid pyributicarb |
Reference:
Schmalfuss, J., Matthes, B, and P. Böger: Chloroacetamide mode of action. Abstr. Meeting Weed Science Society of America, Toronto, 40, 117 – 118, 2000
Schmidt, R. R.: HRAC Classification of Herbicides according to Mode of Action.
Brigton Crop Protection Conference – Weeds 1133-1140, 1997
Information
HRAC
Dr. Robert R. Schmidt
Bayer AG, Monheim
D-51368 Leverkusen, Germany
(
00 49-(0)21 73-38-43 24
Fax 00 49-(0)21 73-38-30 43
e-mail: robert-rudolf.schmidt.rs@bayer-ag.de